Save or Shred?

Answer 4 quick questions about any medical document and get a clear retention recommendation — based on IRS rules, Medicare requirements, and legal best practices.

Step 1 of 4

What type of document is it?

Step 2 of 4

How old is this document?

Step 3 of 4

Is this related to an active dispute?

For example: you're appealing a denied claim, negotiating a bill with the provider, or involved in a billing dispute with your insurer.
Step 4 of 4

Is this document tax-relevant?

HSA/FSA reimbursements, medical expense deductions (Schedule A), or self-employed health insurance premiums.
📄
Retention guidance
Based on the document type and your answers
EOB • Active Dispute

📋 Document Retention at a Glance

Document TypeTypical RetentionAuthority
EOBs1–3 yearsBest practice; match to provider bill cycle
Provider Bills3 years after paymentStatute of limitations (varies by state)
Payment Receipts3 years if tax-claimedIRS limitation period; otherwise varies
HSA ReceiptsKeep with your tax recordsIRS Pub. 969 — substantiation test
FSA ReceiptsPer your plan documentIRS Pub. 969 — FSA rules + plan doc
Denial / Appeal LettersDuration of dispute + 3 yearsLegal best practice
Good Faith Estimates3 years from service dateNo Surprises Act — patient-provider dispute window
Prior Authorizations3 years from serviceInsurance audit window

📚 Why Retention Rules Matter

🏛️ IRS Rules for Medical Expenses

The IRS can generally assess additional tax for up to 3 years after you file (6 years if you understate income by more than 25%). Supporting records should be kept until the period of limitations for that return runs out — usually 3 years, but 2 years from payment for refund/credit claims (whichever is later), 7 years for worthless securities or bad-debt claims, or indefinitely if you never filed or filed a fraudulent return. For HSAs, IRS Publication 969 requires records sufficient to show distributions were used exclusively for qualified medical expenses, were not previously paid or reimbursed from another source, and were not taken as an itemized deduction. FSA reimbursements follow your plan document, not an IRS receipt deadline. See IRS — How long should I keep records?

⚖️ Medical Malpractice Statute of Limitations

Most states allow medical malpractice claims within 1–3 years from the date of injury or discovery. Some states extend to 7 years for foreign objects or fraud. Keeping your records for at least 3 years after treatment preserves your legal options. If you have a complex or ongoing condition, consider keeping records for 7–10 years.

🏥 Medicare & Insurance Audits

Medicare requires providers to retain records for 5 years from the date of service. While this requirement applies to providers (not patients), matching this window ensures you have documentation if your provider's records are questioned. Private insurers typically have a 2–3 year audit window.

📱 No Surprises Act & Good Faith Estimates

If you receive a bill that's at least $400 more than your Good Faith Estimate, you have 120 days to initiate a patient-provider dispute. Keep your GFE for at least 3 years from the service date — this covers the dispute window plus the resolution timeline.

Track All Your Medical Documents — Free & Private

EOBVault helps you organize EOBs, bills, and payment receipts in one place. Scan, categorize, and track every medical expense — no account, no cloud.

Try EOBVault Free →

Need encrypted backup, attachments, or household views? EOBVault Pro — $9 one-time →

❓ Common questions

How long should I keep medical bills and EOBs?
The IRS can generally assess additional tax for up to 3 years after you file (6 years if you understate income by more than 25%). Keep supporting records until the period of limitations for that return runs out — usually 3 years, 7 years for worthless securities or bad-debt claims, and indefinitely if you never filed or filed a fraudulent return.
How long should I keep HSA receipts?
Keep HSA receipts with your tax records. IRS Publication 969 requires records sufficient to show distributions were used exclusively for qualified medical expenses, were not previously paid or reimbursed from another source, and were not taken as an itemized deduction.
How long does Medicare require medical records to be kept?
Medicare requires providers to retain records for 5 years from the date of service. While this applies to providers rather than patients, keeping your own records for the same window ensures you have documentation if your provider's records are ever questioned.
What is the medical malpractice statute of limitations for keeping records?
Most states allow medical malpractice claims within 1–3 years from the date of injury or discovery, with some extending to 7 years for foreign objects or fraud. Keeping your records for at least 3 years after treatment preserves your legal options.
Is this retention guidance official legal or tax advice?
No. The wizard provides general guidance based on IRS rules, Medicare requirements, and common legal standards. Retention requirements vary by state and individual circumstances — consult a qualified professional for your specific situation.